Table of Contents
Foreword / i
Introduction
Part I: Tanrikulu V Turkey / 1 Summary of the case / 5 The facts / 5 The facts as presented by the applicant / 5 The facts as presented by the Government / 6 The proceedings before domestic authorities / 7 The findings of fact of the European Commission on Human Rights (Article 31 report) / 7 The findings of fact of the European Court of Human Rights / 9 Map of the area where the incident occurred / 10 The Legal Proceedings Chronology of events, including legal proceedings / 11 How the case was brought before the European Commission and Court of Human Rights / 12 Investigation hearings under the old procedure / 12 Preliminary objections to the Court’s jurisdiction / 13 The applicant’s complaints under the European Convention on Human Rights Article 2: Right to life / 15 Article 13: Right to an effective remedy / 18 Article 14: Prohibition of discrimination / 19 Article 25(1): Right of individual petition / 19 Just satisfaction: Compensation under Article 41 / 21
Part II: Cakici V Turkey
Summary of the case / 22 The facts / 22 The facts as presented by the applicant / 22 The facts as presented by the Government / 23 The proceedings before domestic authorities / 23 The findings of fact of the European Commission on Human Rights (Article 31 report) / 24 The findings of fact of the European Court of Human Rights / 26 Map of the area where the incident occurred / 27 The Legal Proceedings Chronology of events, including legal proceedings / 28 Preliminary objections to the Court’s jurisdiction / 30 The applicant’s complaints under the European Convention on Human Rights Article 2: Right to life / 31 Article 3: Prohibition of torture / 32 Article 5: Right to liberty and security / 34 Article 13: Right to an effective remedy / 35 Just satisfaction: Compensation under Article 50 / 36
Appendix A: Tanrikulu v Turkey Decision of the European Commission of Human Rights (Article 31 Report), including the admissibility decision Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights Amnesty International Report: South East Turkey, the Health Professions in the Emergency Zone The Susurluk Report (provisional English translation)
Appendix B: Cakiciv Turkey Decision of the European Commission of Human Rights (Article 31 Report), including the admissibility decision Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights |