THE KURDISH EXPERIENCE
Middle East Report
July-August 1994, No. 189, Vol. 24, No. 4
For many decades now, those states whose borders include and divide Kurdistan have alternately tried to ignore, deny, manipulate and suppress widespread Kurdish demands for political rights. In this, the rulers have enjoyed the unstinting support of their great power patrons, the broad support of the majority communities, and often enough support as well among different Kurdish communities and social strata. These policies comprise a disastrous record that has exacted a horrible price in blood, treasure, and democratic rights of Arabs, Iranians and Turks as well as of Kurds themselves. These policies have failed miserably in their repressive goals, and yet they continue as the order of the day....
CONTENTS
THE KURDISH EXPERIENCE
ARTICLES
Amir Hassanpour, The Kurdish Experience / 2
Chris Kutschera, Mad Dreams of Independence: The Kurds of Turkey / 12
Aliza Marcus, City in the War Zone / 16
Ann Zimmerman, Kurdish Broadcasting in Iraq / 20
PHOTO ESSAY
Susan Meiselas-Andrew Whitley, The Remains of Anfal / 8
COLUMN
Maryam Elahi, Washington Watch: Clinton, Ankara and
Kurdish Human Rights / 22
UPDATE
Hugh Roberts, Algeria Between Eradicators and Conciliators / 24
INTERVIEW
Bassam Jarrar-Graham Usher, The Islamist Movement and the Palestinian Authority / 28
REVIEWS
Basil Davidson, Dan Connell “Against All Odds” / 30
Salah Hassan, Salma Khadra Jayyusi “Anthology of Modern Palestinian Literature” / 31
DEPARTMENTS
Editor's Picks: New and Recommended Reading / 32
PHOTOS/ GRAPHICS
Nadia Benchallah, R. Maro, Susan Meiselas, Ann Zimmerman.
Cover Photo: "Saddam wanted to squeeze us."
Halabja, Iraqi Kurdistan. R. Maro/Medico International.
FROM THE EDITORS
For many decades now, those states whose borders include and divide Kurdistan have alternately tried to ignore, deny, manipulate and suppress widespread Kurdish demands for political rights. In this, the rulers have enjoyed the unstinting support of their great power patrons, the broad support of the majority communities, and often enough support as well among different Kurdish communities and social strata. These policies comprise a disastrous record that has exacted a horrible price in blood, treasure, and democratic rights of Arabs, Iranians and Turks as well as of Kurds themselves. These policies have failed miserably in their repressive goals, and yet they continue as the order of the day.
We have tried to highlight here several aspects of the Kurdish experience. One is the tremendous changes over the last two decades, as new economic and social forces, as well as armies, have penetrated and altered Kurdish societies. Another is the persistence of traditional political leaderships and rivalries. As Amir Hassanpour points out, the serious clashes in May 1994 between the two dominant parties of the Kurdish Regional Government, the KDP and the PUK, have similarities with the territorially-based opposition in South Africa of Inkatha to the African National Congress. What is crucially missing, though, is a regional equivalent to the ANC. While the main responsibility for this lies with the Kurdish leadership, other factors play a role the recentness and unevenness of social transformations, the meddling of neighboring rivals Iran and Turkey, and, not least, the punishing economic embargo and political isolation imposed by the United States and other powers as well as by Baghdad.
The US remains, for the moment, a most reluctant "protector" of this experiment in Kurdish self-rule, forced by Turkey's need to stem the refugee crisis that would come with Iraq's reconquest. Here is where we see how little has changed: Western complicity and silence in the face of Baghdad's war of extermination in 1987-88 is reprised, as we write, in the studious inattention to the latest Turkish "final offensive" to crush Kurdish political militancy within its borders. The dimensions of this current campaign are staggering: some 400,000 Turkish troops are deployed against 30,000 guerillas; nearly a thousand villages have been depopulated since 1993; tens of thousands of Kurds in Turkey now seek refuge in Iraq, and hundreds of thousands of others have been displaced within the country. The economic and political crisis which
this war has exacerbated may well trigger a military coup. It is a war that Ankara cannot win, though everyone can lose.
What happens in Turkey where two-thirds of the Kurds live and in the self-rule area of Iraq over the coming months and years is likely to determine the political contours of this region for a long time to come. It is a matter to which we will return. Middle East Report
July-August 1994, No. 189, Vol. 24, No. 4
THE KURDISH EXPERIENCE
Middle East Research & Information Project (MERIP)
Middle East Report
© Copyright; July-August 1994,
Printed in the U.S.A
Middle East Report (ISSN 0899-2851) is published six times a year (bi-monthly) by the Middle East Research and Information Project (MERIP), Inc., Suite 119, 1500 Massachusetts Ave., NW. Washington, DC 20005. Second-class postage paid at Washington, DC POSTMASTER: send address changes to Middle East Report, 1500 Massachusetts Ave, NW, Washington,DC 20005.
Subscriptions are $25 per year for individuals, $50 for institutions. Overseas postage additional. Other rates on inside back cover. Middle East Report is available in microform from University Microfilms, 300 North Zeeb Rd., Ann Arbor, Ml 48106. Canadian Distribution: Doormouse Distribution, 65 Metcalfe St. 6, Toronto M4X,IR9.
Board of Directors: Hady Amr, Dale Bishop, Judith Chomsky, Dan Connell, David Cortright, Nina Dodge, Rhonda Hanson, Donna Nevel, David Nygaard, Doreen Tilghman, John Viste, Andrew Whitley.
Editorial Committee: Joel Beinin, Sheila Carapico, Beshara Doumani, Sally Ethelston, Lisa Hajjar, Barbara Harlow, Joost Hiltermann, Peggy Hutchison, Suad Joseph, Fareed Mohamedi, Julie Peteet, Marsha Pripstein, Yahya Sadowski, Susan Slyomovics, Joe Stork, Bob Vitalis.
Contributing Editors: Ervand Abrahamian, Eqbal Ahmad, Noam Chomsky, Jean-François Clement, Nigel Disney (1951-1978), Marion Farouk-Sluglett, Samih Farsoun, Michael Gilsenan, Sarah Graham-Brown, Alain Gresh, Fred Halliday, Bertus Hendriks, Jochen Hippler, Diane James, Penny Johnson, Rashid Khalidi, Fred Lawson, Ann Lesch, Joan Mandell, Tim Mitchell, Lee O'Brien, Roger Owen, James Paul, Karen Pfeifer, Maxime Rodinson, Miriam Rosen, Philip Shehadi (1957-1991), Mohamed Sid-Ahmed, Salim Tamari, John Tordai, Fawwaz Trabulsi, Judith Tucker, Anita Vitullo, Martha Wenger, Sami Zubaida.
Publisher: Peggy Hutchison
Editor: Joe Stork
Assistant Editor: Maggy Zanger
Circulation Manager: Esther Merves
Administrative Assistant: Ann Schaub
Review Editor: Joel Beinin
Design and Production: Julie Farrar
Interns: Elizabeth Hiel, Deevy Holcomb, Amy Schmidt
Review Intern: Rebecca Stein
Proofreaders: Bryce Giddens, Sarah Shoenfeld
Printing: McArdle Printing Co. |
